Are you a CMO or marketing manager seeing disappointing results from your search traffic strategy? You're not alone. Many businesses struggle to achieve their desired organic search rankings and traffic, despite investing significant time and resources in SEO. One possible reason for this struggle could be that your SEO team is executing a mediocre SEO strategy.

It's a shocking fact: a significant portion of online content fails to gain traction or generate meaningful engagement. One study suggests that as much as 90% of website content is essentially useless to the majority of end users. This "useless" content contributes to the growing problem of Redundant, Obsolete, and Trivial (ROT) data, which not only leads to high storage costs but also has a significant environmental impact. In today's competitive digital landscape, where every click counts, it's crucial to ensure your SEO strategy is effective and delivers tangible results.

This article will explore five key signs that your SEO team might be employing a mediocre strategy, and more importantly, it will provide actionable steps to address these issues and elevate your SEO performance.

1. Poor Website Loading Speed and Neglecting EEAT 👎

Website loading speed is a critical factor in both user experience and SEO. Slow-loading websites can lead to higher bounce rates, lower engagement rates, and decreased user satisfaction. This not only negatively impacts the user experience but can also hurt your SEO rankings. Google has explicitly stated that faster websites are more likely to rank higher in search results.

Furthermore, Google emphasizes the importance of E-E-A-T: Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness. E-E-A-T is a core component of Google's Search Quality Evaluator Guidelines, which are used by human reviewers to assess the quality of Google's search results. While not a quantifiable metric used directly by Google's algorithm, E-E-A-T significantly influences how these reviewers perceive website quality, which can indirectly impact rankings. Websites that demonstrate high levels of E-E-A-T are more likely to be perceived as credible and valuable, leading to better rankings and increased user trust.

It's important to understand that E-E-A-T is not just about the content itself; it's also crucial for user experience (UX) and UI design. A website's design, functionality, and overall user experience contribute to its trustworthiness and authority. For example, a website with a clear and intuitive design, secure payment processing, and readily available contact information will likely be perceived as more trustworthy than a website that is cluttered, difficult to navigate, and lacks essential information.

Signs of a Problem:

- High bounce rates: If users are quickly leaving your website after landing on a page, it could indicate slow loading times or a lack of relevant and engaging content.

- Low average session duration: Users spending minimal time on your site suggests they are not finding the information they need or are having a poor user experience.

- Lack of mobile optimization: In today's mobile-first world, a website that is not optimized for mobile devices will significantly impact user experience and SEO.

- No clear demonstration of expertise or authority: Your website content should clearly showcase the experience, expertise, and authority of the authors or the brand.

Step-by-Step Execution Plan:

StepAction1. Conduct a website speed auditUse tools like Google PageSpeed Insights or GTmetrix to analyze your website's loading speed and identify areas for improvement.2. Optimize imagesCompress images to reduce file sizes without compromising quality.3. Leverage browser cachingEnable browser caching to store website data on the user's device, allowing for faster loading times on subsequent visits.4. Improve server response timeChoose a reliable hosting provider and optimize server configurations to ensure fast response times.5. Minify HTML, CSS, and JavaScriptRemove unnecessary characters and spaces in your code to reduce file sizes.6. Prioritize mobile optimizationEnsure your website is responsive and provides a seamless user experience across all devices.7. Showcase E-E-A-THighlight the experience and expertise of your content creators. Include author bios, credentials, and links to relevant publications or websites.8. Build trust signalsDisplay security badges, customer testimonials, and contact information prominently on your website.

2. Generic and Unengaging Content 👎

Many content writers focus solely on fulfilling their assigned tasks without considering the broader SEO implications. This often results in generic, flat, and boring content that fails to engage users, attract search bots, or generate quality backlinks. To illustrate this point, consider a blog post about "the benefits of exercise." A generic article might simply list common benefits like improved cardiovascular health and weight loss. However, an engaging article would delve deeper, providing specific examples, actionable tips, and perhaps even personal anecdotes to connect with the reader on an emotional level.

Signs of a Problem:

- High bounce rates and low time on page: Users are not finding your content engaging or relevant.

- Low social media engagement: Your content is not being shared or generating discussion on social media platforms.

- Lack of backlinks: Other websites are not linking to your content, indicating a lack of authority or value.

- Keyword stuffing: Your content is overly optimized with keywords, making it sound unnatural and unappealing to readers.

Step-by-Step Execution Plan:

StepAction1. Understand your target audienceConduct thorough research to identify your audience's needs, interests, and search intent.2. Create high-quality, original contentFocus on providing valuable and informative content that addresses your audience's pain points and answers their questions.3. Optimize content for relevant keywordsUse keywords strategically throughout your content, but avoid keyword stuffing.4. Make content visually appealingUse headings, subheadings, bullet points, and images to break up text and improve readability.5. Promote social sharingInclude social sharing buttons on your website and actively promote your content on social media platforms.6. Build internal linksLink to other relevant pages on your website to improve user navigation and distribute link equity.7. Reach out to influencers and bloggersPromote your content to relevant influencers and bloggers in your industry to generate backlinks and increase visibility.

3. Poor Keyword Research and Targeting 👎

While creating engaging and informative content is crucial, it's equally important to ensure that this content is optimized for the right keywords. Many SEO strategies fail to adequately research and target relevant keywords, leading to missed opportunities for organic traffic. Understanding the different types of keywords and how they align with user search intent is essential for effective SEO.

For example, generic keywords like "shoes" have high search volume but are very broad. Branded keywords like "Nike shoes" are more specific and indicate a user's preference for a particular brand. Long-tail keywords, such as "best running shoes for women with flat feet," are even more specific and target a niche audience. An effective SEO strategy should incorporate a mix of these keyword types to maximize reach and attract the right audience.

Signs of a Problem:

- Low organic traffic: Your website is not attracting sufficient organic traffic from search engines.

- High bounce rates: Users are landing on your website but not finding the information they are looking for.

- Low conversion rates: Users are not taking desired actions on your website, such as making a purchase or filling out a contact form.

Step-by-Step Execution Plan:

StepAction1. Conduct thorough keyword researchUse keyword research tools like Semrush or Ahrefs to identify relevant keywords with high search volume and low competition.2. Analyze search intentUnderstand the user's intent behind each keyword to create content that aligns with their needs.3. Categorize keywordsGroup keywords into different categories (generic, branded, long-tail) to develop a comprehensive keyword strategy.4. Optimize content for target keywordsUse keywords strategically throughout your content, including in titles, headings, and meta descriptions.5. Track keyword rankingsMonitor your website's ranking for target keywords to assess the effectiveness of your strategy.

4. Neglecting Other Critical Marketing Channels 👎

A truly effective SEO strategy should not operate in isolation. It needs to be integrated with other critical marketing channels, such as email marketing, social media, press releases, and local SEO. By neglecting these channels, you are missing out on valuable opportunities to amplify your SEO efforts and reach a wider audience.

For instance, email marketing can be a powerful tool for driving high-quality traffic to your website, which in turn boosts off-page SEO by encouraging beneficial user behavior like sharing, commenting, and exploring other website pages. A study by eMarketer found that email marketing gives back a 122% return on investment.

Social media also plays a crucial role in SEO. Well-optimized social media profiles can contribute to a website's SEO by improving visibility and increasing social signals. This includes adding relevant keywords in social profile descriptions and bios, as well as linking to your website on your social media profiles.

Press releases, when crafted with an SEO focus, can be a powerful tool for sharing your news with media outlets and increasing visibility in search engines. They can increase mentions of your brand across the web, signaling expertise and trustworthiness to search engines.

Signs of a Problem:

- SEO efforts are siloed: Your SEO team is not collaborating with other marketing teams.

- Lack of social media presence: Your brand has a minimal or inactive presence on social media platforms.

- No email marketing strategy: You are not leveraging email marketing to nurture leads and drive website traffic.

- Local SEO is ignored: If you have a local business, neglecting local SEO can significantly impact your visibility in local search results.

Step-by-Step Execution Plan:

StepAction1. Integrate SEO with other marketing channelsFoster collaboration between your SEO team and other marketing teams to ensure a cohesive strategy.2. Develop a comprehensive social media strategyCreate engaging content, optimize social media profiles, and actively participate in relevant social media communities.3. Build an email list and nurture leadsUse email marketing to share valuable content, promote offers, and drive traffic to your website.4. Optimize press releases for SEOInclude relevant keywords, links to your website, and distribute press releases through reputable channels.5. Optimize for local SEOClaim your Google My Business profile, ensure consistent NAP citations, and build local backlinks.

5. SEO Reports Lacking Focus on Key KPIs 👎

Many SEO reports focus on vanity metrics that don't necessarily translate into meaningful business outcomes. Instead of tracking metrics like keyword rankings or website traffic alone, it's crucial to focus on KPIs that directly align with your business goals. SEO campaigns touch on a multitude of measurable components, and it's easy to get lost in the data. However, the most effective reports focus on the key performance indicators that truly matter.

For example, if your primary goal is to generate leads, your SEO report should prioritize metrics like conversion rates, lead generation forms, and the number of leads generated from organic search traffic. If your goal is to increase brand awareness, the report should focus on metrics like website traffic, social media engagement, and brand mentions.

Signs of a Problem:

- Reports are filled with irrelevant data: The reports include a lot of data, but it's not clear how it relates to business objectives.

- Lack of actionable insights: The reports don't provide clear recommendations for improvement or highlight areas of concern.

- No focus on conversion rates: The reports don't track how SEO efforts are contributing to leads, sales, or other conversions.

Step-by-Step Execution Plan:

StepAction1. Define clear business objectivesIdentify the specific goals you want to achieve with your SEO strategy (e.g., increase leads, drive sales, improve brand awareness).2. Select relevant KPIsChoose KPIs that directly measure progress towards your business objectives (e.g., conversion rates, lead generation, revenue from organic search).3. Track and analyze data regularlyMonitor your SEO performance on a regular basis and analyze the data to identify trends, areas for improvement, and opportunities for optimization.4. Create concise and actionable reportsFocus on presenting key findings and insights in a clear and concise manner, with clear recommendations for action.

Bonus Issue! No Budget for Paid Traffic to Boost Engagement Signals 👎

Many SEO strategies overlook the importance of paid traffic in boosting the engagement signals of important pages. Paid traffic can help increase visibility, drive traffic, and generate social engagement, which can indirectly improve organic rankings. This is because paid traffic can bring in visitors who genuinely engage with the content, sending positive signals to search engines about the relevance and value of your website.

For example, if you have a landing page that is not ranking well organically, you can use paid advertising to drive targeted traffic to that page. This increased traffic and engagement can signal to search engines that the page is valuable and relevant, potentially leading to improved organic rankings over time.

Signs of a Problem:

- Reliance solely on organic traffic: Your SEO strategy does not incorporate any paid advertising campaigns.

- Low engagement on key pages: Important pages on your website are not receiving sufficient traffic or engagement.

- Missed opportunities for brand awareness: You are not leveraging paid advertising to increase brand visibility and reach a wider audience.

Step-by-Step Execution Plan:

StepAction1. Identify key pagesDetermine the most important pages on your website that you want to boost in search rankings.2. Allocate budget for paid trafficSet aside a portion of your marketing budget for paid advertising campaigns.3. Use targeted advertisingUtilize platforms like Google Ads or social media advertising to target specific audiences and drive traffic to your key pages.4. Track and analyze campaign performanceMonitor the performance of your paid campaigns and make adjustments as needed to optimize results.

Conclusion

By addressing these six signs of a mediocre SEO strategy, CMOs and marketing managers can significantly improve their website's organic search performance and achieve their desired business outcomes. Remember that SEO is an ongoing process that requires continuous monitoring, analysis, and optimization.

By staying informed about the latest trends and best practices, and by actively adapting your strategy to meet the evolving needs of your audience and the search landscape, you can ensure your SEO efforts deliver lasting results.

This means not only focusing on technical aspects like website speed and keyword optimization but also on creating high-quality, engaging content that resonates with your target audience. It also means integrating your SEO strategy with other critical marketing channels to maximize reach and impact. By taking a holistic and data-driven approach to SEO, you can drive more qualified traffic to your website, increase brand awareness, generate more leads, and ultimately achieve your business objectives.

Take action today to elevate your SEO strategy from mediocre to exceptional!

Bibliography:

- "90% of your website is useless." Service Design Magazine, 2025, URL. Accessed 1 Jan. 2025.

- "Useless data and carbon waste; the dark side of digitization." TechRadar, 2025, URL. Accessed 1 Jan. 2025.

- "How Does Page Speed Affect SEO?" Goodman Creatives, 2025, URL. Accessed 1 Jan. 2025.

- "What does E-A-T mean in SEO?" Moz, 2025, URL. Accessed 1 Jan. 2025.

- "What Is E-E-A-T and How Does It Impact SEO? ." Siege Media, 2025, URL. Accessed 1 Jan. 2025.

- "What Is E-E-A-T? Why Is E-E-A-T Important For SEO?" SEO Inc., 2025, URL. Accessed 1 Jan. 2025.

- "7 Types of SEO Content to Boost Your Visibility." Slickplan, 2025, URL. Accessed 1 Jan. 2025.

- "16 Types of SEO Keywords (+How to Find & Use Them)." LocaliQ, 2025, URL. Accessed 1 Jan. 2025.

- "How Combining SEO and Email Marketing for Better Results on SERPs." Maropost, 2025, URL. Accessed 1 Jan. 2025.

- "Can Social Media Help Your SEO in 2024?" Coalition Technologies, 2025, URL. Accessed 1 Jan. 2025.

- "Do Press Releases Help SEO? Benefits & Best Practices." PR Newswire, 2025, URL. Accessed 1 Jan. 2025.

- "7 Most Important SEO KPIs for Outstanding Results." Data Bloo, 2025, URL. Accessed 1 Jan. 2025.

- "Why are your SEO Performance Reports being ignored?" Blue Array, 2025, URL. Accessed 1 Jan. 2025.

- "How Does Paid Search Impact Organic SEO?" 321 Web Marketing, 2025, URL. Accessed 1 Jan. 2025.

- "Can paid traffic increase or influence organic rankings?" Reddit, 2025, URL. Accessed 1 Jan. 2025. https://speed.cy/seo/underperforming-seo-team